[Rosa was too busy worrying about her life as well as the lives of the children to solve any epitaphs at the time. But somehow this person was saying they had earned the magic of Beatrice by solving the epitaph.]

There were only nineteen people, including the Witch, on the island at the time. I know most of them were in no place to solve the epitaph. Don't tell me. Father hid some other child away on the island, and you took advantage of Beatrice's antics.